The Foundations of Legislative Ethics from the Perspective of Maqasid al-Wahy in al-Shatibi's Thought

Nikkho Amiri, N.; Karimi, S.; Tabatabaie, S.M.

doi:10.58209/jpt.6.1.19

The Foundations of Legislative Ethics from the Perspective of Maqasid al-Wahy in al-Shatibi's Thought

Document Type : Original Research

Authors

N. Nikkho Amiri

S. Karimi

S.M. Tabatabaie

Department of Contemporary Philosophy, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran

https://doi.org/10.58209/jpt.6.1.19

Abstract

The ideal legislator in this study is one who upholds propriety, ethics, and the principles of legislation. This study examines the ethical foundations of legislation through Imam al-Shatibi’s theory of Maqasid al-Shari’ah. By emphasizing the five objectives—preservation of religion, life, intellect, lineage, and property—al-Shatibi formulates a moral and rational framework that places legislation in service of the public good. His distinction between devotional acts and transactions, acceptance of analogy in rational matters, and differentiation between Meccan and Medinan revelations establish a dynamic balance between fixed and adaptable Shari’ah principles. Grounded in the precedence of revelation over reason, al-Shatibi views lawmaking as an ethical process bound by divine limits and human welfare. This perspective offers valuable guidance for contemporary Islamic legislation amid technological, social, and moral challenges.

Keywords

al-Shatibi, Maqasid al-Shari&‌‌rsquo

ah, Ethics of Legislation, Public Interest, Narration, Reason

Subjects

Philosophy of Ethics (Modern)

- A Group of Authors (2013a). Zayed encyclopedia of jurisprudential and fundamental rules (Volume 3). Abu Dhabi: Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan Charitable and Humanitarian Foundation, Organization of Islamic Cooperation. [Arabic]
- A Group of Authors (2013b). Zayed encyclopedia of jurisprudential and fundamental rules (Volume 5). Abu Dhabi: Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan Charitable and Humanitarian Foundation, Organization of Islamic Cooperation. [Arabic]
- Al-Ghazali AH (2014). AL-MUSTASFA MIN ‘ILM AL-USUL (Volume 2). Umar AMM, editor. Beirut: DAR AL-KUTUB AL-‘ILMIYYAH. [Arabic]
- Al-Raysuni A (1997). The objectives of religion from Al-Shatibi’s perspective. Islami SH, Abhari SMA, translators. Qom: BUSTAN-E KETAB. [Persian]
- Al-Raysuni A (2010). MADKHAL ELA MAQASID AL-SHARI‘AH. Cairo: DAR AL-KALIMA Publishing and Distribution. [Arabic]
- Al-Shatibi AI (2009). AL-MUWAFAQAT FI USUL AL-SHARI‘AH. Daraz MA, editor. Beirut: DAR AL-KUTUB AL-‘ILMIYYAH. [Arabic]
- Bentham J (1979). The theory of legislation. Ogden CK, editor. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
- Fanaei A (2016). Religion on the scale of ethics. Tehran: Serat Publications. [Persian]
- Hallaq W (2016). A history of Islamic legal theories. Rasekh M, translator. Tehran: Ney Publications. [Persian]
- Hobbollah H (2020). AL-IJTIHAD AL-MAQASIDI WA AL-MANATI: AL-MASARAT WA AL-USUL WA AL-‘AWA’IQ WA AL-TA’THIRAT (IJTIHAD AL-MA‘NA FI USUL AL-FIQH AL-ISLAMI) (Volume 1). Beirut: DAR RAWAFID. [Arabic]
- Ibn Taymiyyah (2004). MAJMU‘ AL-FATAWA (Volume 1). Ibn Qasim ARM, editor. Madinah: MAJMA ALMALIK FAHD LETABA’T ALMUSHAF ALSHARIF. [Arabic]
- Karimi S, Aghajani M (2024). Assessing the epistemological position of analogy in the system of jurisprudential inference with a focus on the separation of godliness versus transactions. Journal of Philosophy of Law. 3(1):123-150. [Persian]
- Mas’ud MK (2013). The philosophy of Islamic law. Zafari MR, Asghari Aghmashhadi F, translators. Qom: BUSTAN-E KETAB Publications. [Persian]
- Morawetz T (2012). Philosophy of law: Foundations and functions. Jondaghi B, translator. Qom: Research Institute of Hawzah and University. [Persian]
- Plato (1999). Euthyphro. Jowett B, translator. Montclair, NJ: Project Gutenberg.
- Preston N (1998). Legislative ethics: Challenges and prospects. In: Preston N, Sampford C, editors. Ethics and political practice: Perspectives on legislative ethics. London: Routledge. p. 143-152.
- Qaradawi Y (2013). A study on the purposes of SHARI‘AH. Shafaeian A, Asadi SR, translators. Tehran: Ehsan Publications. [Persian]
- Rachels J, Rachels S (2018). The elements of moral philosophy. 9th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- Sobhani J (2021). MARZBANI AZ MAKTAB-I AHL AL-BAYT. Mu’assasah-yi Farhangi Hunari-yi Mash’ar. [Arabic]
- Waldron J (2018). Legislation: Concepts, theories, and principles. Vakilian H, translator. Tehran: NEGAH-E MOASER Publications. [Persian]