تاثیر میراث منطقی "علامه ملاعبدالله بهابادی" بر تکوین سبک استدلالی قاعده‌بنیاد نزد "علامه سیدمحمدحسین طباطبایی"

نوع مقاله : پژوهشی اصیل

نویسنده

اداره آموزش و پرورش ناحیه یک، وزارت آموزش و پرورش، یزد، ایران

چکیده
این پژوهش با روش تحلیلی-تطبیقی و تاریخی-متنی، جایگاه علامه ملاعبدالله بهابادی را به عنوان یکی از معماران سنت آموزش منطق در جهان اسلام بررسی می‌کند. با وجود فاصله چهارصدساله که تاثیر مستقیم را ناممکن می‌سازد، تمرکز بر انتقال غیرمستقیم این سنت و زبان مشترک منطق است. علامه طباطبایی، ساختار برهانی حاشیه تهذیب المنطق ملاعبدالله بهابادی را درونی کرده و در آثارش مانند بدایة‌الحکمة، نهایة‌الحکمة و المیزان به کار بسته است. نوآوری‌های او در تداوم یک سنت منطقی-فکری بود که علامه بهابادی از معماران کلیدی آن است. این مطالعه تاکید می‌کند که سبک استدلالی قاعده‌بنیاد، بدنمند و عقل‌گرای علامه طباطبایی نتیجه تداوم سنتی انتقال منطق از طریق زنجیره آموزشی حوزوی و تاثیر حاشیه علامه بهابادی بر نظام فکری ایشان است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات

- Abdipour H (2016). A study and analysis of the scientific and practical conduct of Allameh Molla Abdollah Bahabadi Yazdi. Yazd: Secretariat of the International Congress of Allameh Molla Abdollah Bahabadi Yazdi. [Persian]
- Akrami M (2017). From logic in Islam to Islamic logic. Logica Universalis. 11(1):61-83.
- Al-Saedi RM (2024). Marginal notes on the intellectual and logical aspects of Allameh Abdullah Yazdi. In: MAJMU’EH-YE MAQALAT-E Molla Abdullah Bahabadi Yazdi (2). Yazd: Secretariat of the International Congress of Allameh Molla Abdollah Bahabadi Yazdi. [Persian]
- Anderson JR, Crawford J (1995). Cognitive psychology and its implications. New York: W.H. Freeman. 
- Aqa Bozorg Al-Tehrani MM (1982). AL-DHARIA' ILA TASANEEF AL-SHIA (Volume 6). Beirut: DAR AL-ADWA. [Arabic]
- Aqa Bozorg Al-Tehrani MM (2017). TABAQAT A‘LAM AL-SHI‘AH: NUQABA’ AL-BASHAR FI AL-QARN AL-RABI‘ ‘ASHAR (Volume 2). Tehran: Library, Museum and Documentation Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly & Islamic Research Foundation of Astan Quds Razavi. [Arabic]
- Avani G (2011). Rethinking Philosophy in an Oriental Way. JAVIDAN KHERAD. 7(17):5-20. [Persian]
- Bahramnejad M (2018). A historical reflection on the Sinavi logic in the Safavid period. Science and Religion Studies. 9(1):99-120. [Persian]
- Bazeli R (2016). Evident propositions and their divisions from the perspective of Mollah Abdullah Yazdi in Hashiyeh. In: MAJMU'EH-YE MAQALAT-E Mollah Abdullah Bahabadi Yazdi. Yazd: Secretariat of the International Congress of Allameh Molla Abdollah Bahabadi Yazdi. p. 123-147. [Persian]
- Bhat AM (2019). Islamic philosophy of education. Journal of Culture and Values in Education. 2(2):73-76.
- Bourdieu P, Passeron JC (1990). Reproduction in education, society and culture (Volume 4). Thousand Oaks: Sage. 
- Daneshyar M (2012). The term of Hawza Ilmiyya: A history of its appearance and the semantic evolution. Iranian Journal for the History of Islamic Civilization. 45(1):81-93. [Persian]
- Ebrahimpour A, Moalimi H (2023). Separation of the truth of “science” and “mental existence” the conceptology of “philosophy of the Islamic logic” and knowing the background of its issues in the heritage of the Islamic logic. Journal of the Islamic Wisdom Teachings. 1(1):39-66. [Persian]
- Faramarz Qaramelaki A, Abedi MG (2016). TARIFE MANTEQ. Qom: Majnun Publications. [Persian]
- Fayezi MH, Mousavinasab MS (2025). The historical evolution of moral education in the Islamic Seminary (Ḥawza) of Qom during the last century. Journal of Islamic Education. 20(54):147-184. [Persian]
- Gerashi M, Khalifeh A (2025). The importance of an education-oriented approach to neo-Sadrian logic and epistemology in defining scientific terms: A case study on 'Technology'. Journal of Philosophical Investigations. 19(50):437-464. [Persian]
- Hoseini Mazandarani M (1964). SHARHE NAFISE HASHIYEH-YE MOLLA ABDOLLAH: TAHZIB AL-MANTIQ VAL-KALAM (Volume 2). Qom: Tabatabai Press Institute. [Persian]
- Hosseini Tehrani SMH (2005). The radiant sun. Mashhad: Allameh Tabatabai Publications. [Persian]
- Khansari M (1982). Formal logic (Volume 1). Tehran: Agah. [Persian]
- King DA (1978). "Islamic science", by SH Nasr. Journal for the History of Astronomy. 9(3):201. 
- Maddahi M (2020). The history of education in Shi ‘i (Hawza)-Karbala Hawza as a Model. Karbala Heritage: Quarterly Authorized Journal Specialized in Karbala Heritage. 7(1, 2). 
- Mahmoodzadeh J, Hooshangi H (2023). Levels of practical rationality in the thought of Allameh Tabatabai. Religious Anthropology. 20(49):47-59. [Persian]
- Melia T (1992). The Literary Structure of Scientific Argument: Historical Studies (Review). Isis. 83(1):100-106. 
- Moore JW (2009). The logic of definition. Philosophy, Political Science.
- Muzaffar MR (2000). AL-MANTIQ. Qom: DAFTAR-E INTISHARAT-E ISLAMI. [Arabic]
- Nasr SH (1980). Science and civilization in Islam. Aram A, translator. Tehran: Kharazmi Publishing Company. [Persian]
- Nozari M, Zareii Rezaii MH (2022). The methods of intellectual education from the point of view of Allameh Tabatabai. Transcendent Training. 1(2):7-24. [Persian]
- Sadri MS (1994). Caravan of science and faith: Biographies of prominent men and celebrities of Iran. Tehran: Shaghayegh. [Persian]
- Safi Golpaygani A (2009). The course of Shi'ite seminaries. Karimi A, editor. Qom: MARKAZE TANZIM VA NASHRE ASARE HAZRATE AYATOLLAH AL-OZMA SAFI GOLPAYGANI. [Persian]
- Tabatabaei Lotfi SAM, Qasemi T (2016). A descriptive study of Mullah Abdullah Behbahadi’s marginalia from the perspective of educational stylistics. In: MAJMU'EH-YE MAQALAT-E Mollah Abdullah Bahabadi Yazdi. Yazd: Secretariat of the International Congress of Allameh Molla Abdollah Bahabadi Yazdi. p. 21-32. [Persian]
- Tabatabai SMH (1995). AL-MIZAN FI TAFSIR AL-QUR'AN. Musavi Hamadani SMB, translator. Qom: DAFTAR-E INTISHARAT-E ISLAMI. [Persian]
- Tabatabai SMH (1997). The beginning of wisdom. Shirvani A, translator. Qom: DAFTAR-E INTISHARAT-E ISLAMI. [Persian]
- Tabatabai SMH (1999). The end of wisdom. Shirvani A, translator. Qom: DAFTAR-E INTISHARAT-E ISLAMI. [Persian]
- Wuthnow R (1979). The emergence of modern science and world system theory. Theory and Society. 8(2):215-243. 
- Yasin R, Jani MS (2013). Islamic education: The philosophy, aim, and main features. International Journal of Education and Research. 1(10):1-18. 
- Yazdi AH (1992). AL-HASHIYAH ALA TAHDHIB AL-MANTIQ. Qom: DAFTAR-E INTISHARAT-E ISLAMI. [Arabic]
- Zohreh Kashani AA (2018). The 1200-year history of the Qom seminary: With an educational and research approach. Qom: Research Institute of Hawzah and University. [Persian]
دوره 6، شماره 1
زمستان 1404
صفحه 109-124

  • تاریخ دریافت 02 اردیبهشت 1405
  • تاریخ انتشار 01 دی 1404